As readers may be aware, I was fortunate enough to win two properties in the Bay Area — one last year in 2012, and another this past February 2013. As luck would have it, each property has appreciated close to $100,000/each. There’s a lot of equity tied up in these Bay Area properties (appreciation and downpayment), and I’ve been itching to pull some of this back out so that I can reinvest it.
The problem is, I elected to use one of the bigger banks for lending, and am now just realizing how painful it is trying to pull the equity out. I’m an investor, and it seems like the big name banks are more accustomed to dealing with owner occupied clients. This week, I’ve been working on trying to secure a home equity line of credit (HELOC) from Rental Property #1, and have been unsuccessful. It’s been a royal pain in the you know what… for the following reasons:
- Lender will only allow 35% debt-to-income ratio.
- Lender won’t count rental income for any of my properties (Rental Property #1 won’t clear 2 year seasoning requirement until 2013 tax returns are filed. Rental Property #2-4 don’t appear on ANY tax returns currently. So, my debt-to-income is way out of whack, and well exceeds 35%.)
- Lender will only loan up to 65% of appraised value of property.
Let’s use an example. Rental Property #1 was purchased for $315,000. Market value today is roughly $420,000. The lender will loan up to 65% of the appraised value, or $273,000. My remaining debt is roughly $229,000. Thus, I would have access to $44,000.
In this real world example, the final results aren’t too bad. Actually, $44,000 would go a long ways towards helping me secure another downpayment, so I would take it in a heartbeat. Still, being able to access ONLY $44,000, when I have over $80,000 in principal and $100,000 in appreciation seems a bit unfair. Now I’m questioning why any sane investor would want to get a loan through these investor-unfriendly banks.
Not only is it next to impossible to access the equity due to the seasoning requirement, but even had they let me open a line of credit, I would have been limited to only 65% of the appraised value. Again, the real world example works, luckily, because the local appreciation has been so insane. But suppose it wasn’t a Bay Area property, and one of my other rentals out-of-state… What choices would I have then? Using a big name bank, not many, unfortunately. Without insane appreciation to drive up the appraisal, 65% of the home’s value minus the remaining debt service leaves you with… close to zero.
Let’s use Rental Property #3 as an example. It was purchased for roughly $160,000. Let’s say market value shot up to $190,000. After subtracting out the ~$118,000 debt service, the line of credit available would be a measly $5500 or so. Definitely not much to get excited about.
For those considering buying rental properties, make sure you work with an investor-friendly lender. I’m learning my lesson the hard way… I want my equity back!
p.s. I’m going to attempt to reach out to some small, local lenders this week. Hopefully, someone will be nice enough to lend to me. 🙂